Id. at Tr. 32. The campus moreover has eleven gender-neutral single-stall bathrooms in varied places that are open to any scholar or employees member. Additionally, if a transgender student enrolled in the St. Johns County School District having already modified their authorized paperwork to reflect their gender id, the student’s college records would replicate that gender as properly. 115. However, the varsity Board is not aware of any bullying violations involving a transgender student in any St. Johns County School District restroom, id. Id. at Tr. 69, 111, 115. A associated concern raised by the retired Director of Student Services was that beneath a relaxed policy, a student-a football participant for instance-could pose as being gender-fluid for the aim of gaining access to the girls’ restroom, however the college would haven’t any way to know whether his perception that he is gender-fluid is honest. They do not prefer to inform you exactly what steel this alleged “bullion” is, besides they all the time swear it does not have any mercury in it. If your house is in need of a critical repair, like a leaky roof, busted plumbing, a defunct HVAC (heating, ventilation, air conditioning) system or a mold drawback, then that can most definitely be a degree of contention.
Id. at Tr. 35-36, 53. The college Board Attorney testified that he thought that situation can be a uncommon occurrence and, if it became a problem, the varsity Board might re-study the follow of utilizing self-identifying enrollment paperwork to determine gender. ” and it accepts the knowledge on the enrollment documents at face worth. Id. at Tr. 54-55. However, he agreed that at this point, the college District would don’t have any occasion to question a scholar who used a restroom according to the gender recorded on the student’s enrollment documents. 219-20. Moreover, the retired Director of Student Services acknowledged that for a transgender student who has made the social transition and whose look is constant along with his or her gender identification (for instance, a transgender lady whose hair is long, whose breasts are enhanced, who’s wearing lipstick), there may be security, security, and privacy considerations if that student used the restroom that is per the intercourse the pupil was assigned at delivery; thus, she thought it could be preferable if such a pupil used a gender-neutral single-stall bathroom. Id. at Tr. 248. The varsity Board Attorney additionally defined that allowing a transgender scholar to make use of a restroom that conformed to his or her gender id could create opportunities for college kids “with untoward intentions to do things they ought to not do,” although the school Board has by no means acquired any complaints of untoward habits involving a transgender scholar.
53. Thus, until there was a complaint, a transgender student might use the restroom matching his or her gender id till he or she graduated and the college would be none the wiser. Through the summer time of 2015, earlier than Adams started high school at Nease, Adams’ mom knowledgeable the student services department that Adams was transitioning and can be attending highschool as a boy. Id. at Tr. 253. Sooner or later in September approximately six weeks after college started, Adams was referred to as out from his classroom and advised by his steerage counselor that somebody had complained about him utilizing the boys’ restroom and that, going ahead, he may use the gender-neutral bathroom in the college workplace. Id. at Tr. 117-18. It was not a boy or a boy’s dad and mom who had complained. 116. As Adams testified, “I was residing in every facet of my life as a boy and now they’re taking that away from me.” Id. 251-52. When Adams started college in August, he introduced as a boy and used the boys’ restroom when wanted without incident. Id. at Tr. 115-16. The varsity agreed to supply gender-impartial restrooms which Adams has used as needed.
The urinals within the boys’ restrooms will not be divided by partitions, although a faculty official said perhaps they may very well be. Id. at Tr. 133. All the boys’ restrooms have a set of urinals and stalls with doorways. A couple of months ago, I requested a sister whom I do have a relationship with to take my young son for two weeks at her home within the Midwest and requested that my other sister, because of our strained relationship and the pandemic, not be allowed to visit him. Rather, it was two unidentified feminine college students who reported that they had seen Adams entering the boys’ restroom. Id. at Tr. 172-73. Adams could be topic to disciplinary action if he used the boys’ bathroom. Adams stated he was confused, shocked, and angered by the school’s reaction. There are four units of multi-stall, sex-segregated bathrooms out there throughout class time to the school’s 2,450 students. To Adams, the school’s refusal to let him use the boys’ restroom meant that the college did not see him as a boy, and refused to simply accept who he was. The varsity principal stated there are often traces to use those bathrooms.